Kathryn Stockett spent more than a decade off the bestseller lists after “The Help” turned her into a publishing phenomenon, and “The Calamity Club” makes the wait feel worthwhile from the moment its three very different heroines share a page.
Set in Oxford, Mississippi, in 1933, the novel follows eleven-year-old Meg, left in an orphanage by a mother she barely remembers; Birdie, an unmarried bookkeeper who comes home hunting for a way to keep her family solvent and winds up auditing the orphanage’s accounts instead; and Charlie, a woman backed into a corner by circumstance who hatches an audacious scheme to hand all three of them a say in their own futures. Stockett threads their converging stories through the hard realities of the Depression-era South, poverty, the eugenics movement and forced-sterilization laws of the period, child labor, adoption practices, and Prohibition-era bootlegging, without ever letting the history swamp the human stakes at the center of the book.
What carries the novel is the same gift Stockett showed in her debut: dialogue that sounds lived-in rather than written, and a sense of place specific enough that you can practically smell the kudzu on the page. Meg, Birdie, and Charlie are drawn as women pushing against the narrow lanes their society cut for them, and the unlikely alliance they build across lines of age and class gives the book its emotional charge. The pacing rewards patience, since the plot’s various threads take their time braiding together, but the payoff, when the calamity club finally springs its plan, lands with real satisfaction.
Early reviews have been largely enthusiastic, with major outlets pointing to the propulsive plotting and richly voiced characters as the book’s chief strengths. Several critics have also noted that the story is narrated exclusively from white perspectives despite its setting in a Depression-era Mississippi Black community, and a few felt the final chapters resolve a touch too neatly given the darker material the novel raises along the way. Even so, the overall critical consensus lands much closer to “hard to put down” than not, and the audiobook edition in particular has drawn praise for its performances.
“The Calamity Club” isn’t quite the lightning-in-a-bottle that “The Help” was, but it doesn’t need to be. It’s a warm, briskly told story about women refusing to accept the futures handed to them, and it earns its spot atop the bestseller lists honestly. Readers who like their historical fiction with a side of righteous mischief will find plenty here to love, and Stockett fans who have waited years for a follow-up should feel it was worth the wait.
As an Amazon Associate, VIRA Broadcasting earns from qualifying purchases.