Ten years ago, “Pardon My Take” was two guys yelling about football into microphones for a Barstool Sports audience that hadn’t fully materialized yet. Today it’s arguably the biggest sports podcast in the country, and “Pardon My Book” is its hosts cashing in a decade of chaos for something you can actually put on a shelf, assuming your shelf can handle that much nonsense.
Big Cat (Dan Katz) and PFT Commenter (Eric Sollenberger) built the show on a specific formula: real sports knowledge delivered with maximum irreverence, a rotating cast of bits that somehow calcified into institutions, and a tolerance for stupidity that reads as strategy in hindsight. The book tries to bottle all of it. There’s an origin story for the show, a history of “Grit Week,” a set of tongue-in-cheek rules for podcasting success, guest testimonials from actual sports media legends like Joe Buck and Adam Schefter, and a grab bag of contributor bits, PFT’s fullback rankings, Big Cat’s gambling commandments, a painfully sincere Mount Rushmore of Italian American athletes, that reads less like a cohesive memoir and more like a yearbook assembled by everyone who’s ever been in the room.
That yearbook approach is both the book’s charm and its liability. When it works, which is often, “Pardon My Book” captures the specific alchemy that makes the podcast addictive: inside jokes that reward loyal listeners without fully locking out newcomers, and a genuine affection between collaborators that comes through even in the most absurd tangents. Readers who’ve spent years with the show describe it as something closer to a reunion than a book, stuffed with behind-the-scenes color about the guests, the bits, and the near-decade of “grit” that got them here.
Where it draws more mixed reaction is execution. Because so many hands touched this thing, the tone swings hard from chapter to chapter, and more than a few readers have flagged rough editing, stray typos, and prose that occasionally reads like a lightly cleaned-up transcript rather than considered writing. For a book from a major publisher, that inconsistency stands out, though a fair number of fans have decided the roughness is actually on brand for a show that has never pretended to be polished. Critically, the reception has landed in a similar place: strong praise for the nostalgia and the sheer density of behind-the-scenes material, tempered by acknowledgment that the collage structure means some sections land better than others, and that the book rewards existing fans far more than curious newcomers.
None of that has slowed it down commercially. “Pardon My Book” arrived as a #1 New York Times bestseller and has held the top of Amazon’s media and sports-history categories since release, evidence that the show’s audience was more than ready to pay for a physical artifact of the last decade.
Is it great literature? Obviously not, and it isn’t trying to be. It’s a loud, occasionally sloppy, frequently funny scrapbook from a show that built an empire on being exactly that. For anyone who has spent a commute or a workout laughing along with Big Cat and PFT, “Pardon My Book” is less a purchase than a reunion, warts, weird tangents, and all.
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, VIRA Broadcasting earns from qualifying purchases. This post contains affiliate links.