Maggie O’Farrell has never been a writer content to tell a story straight through when a stranger, more elemental path is available, and “Land” pushes that instinct further than anything in her catalog since “Hamnet.” This is a novel about a family, yes, but it’s just as much a novel about a piece of ground — what it remembers, what it withholds, and what it does to the people who try to make a life on top of a wound that hasn’t healed.
The book opens in 1865 on Ireland’s famine-scarred west coast, in the stunned quiet that followed the Great Hunger. Tomás, a taciturn surveyor working for the British, and his ten-year-old son Liam have been mapping place names and boundaries, translating a landscape for people who never lived in it. After the two of them emerge from a strange, half-wild copse of trees, Tomás abruptly quits the job. He wants to make, in his words, a map of how the land really is — not how the Crown wants it drawn. He sinks the family’s savings into leasing the ground near that copse, and moves his wife and children into a ruined cottage abandoned during the famine years. From there, O’Farrell tunnels into the lives of Tomás and his wife Phina’s four children, each born into the aftermath of catastrophe and each pulled toward something different — music, faith, labor, the pull of the land itself — in a quiet, aching study of the Irish diaspora in miniature.
What makes “Land” remarkable is O’Farrell’s refusal to structure it like a conventional family saga. The novel behaves more like the terrain it describes: circling back, doubling on itself, letting silence and landscape carry as much weight as dialogue. It’s a formal risk, and it pays off — the writing has the hushed, watchful quality of a folk tale, steeped in Irish history without ever feeling like a history lesson. O’Farrell’s prose has always rewarded patience, and here that patience is the point; she’s less interested in what happens to this family than in how the land itself absorbs, distorts, and eventually releases what happened to them.
Critics have responded to the novel with the kind of reverence O’Farrell has come to expect. Reviewers have praised its evocative, folklore-infused atmosphere and its formal ambition, with more than one comparing its structure to the terrain it depicts rather than a traditional plot. There’s broad agreement that O’Farrell is working at the height of her powers here, using this one family’s fracture to illuminate the much larger legacy of imperialism, religious control, and the famine’s long shadow over Irish life. If there’s a recurring caveat, it’s that the novel’s unhurried, impressionistic pacing asks more of readers than her more propulsive earlier work — this is not a book to rush.
“Land” confirms O’Farrell as one of the era’s most formally daring historical novelists, a writer willing to let a landscape do the emotional work a lesser book would hand to plot. It’s demanding in the best sense: slow, haunted, and generous to those willing to sit with it. Highly recommended, especially to readers who loved the strange stillness at the center of “Hamnet.”
As an Amazon Associate, VIRA Broadcasting earns from qualifying purchases.