The opening week of the 2025 NFL preseason delivered its share of surprises, with rising stars making their mark and others faltering under the spotlight. From Cleveland Browns rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders leading scoring drives to Dallas Cowboys backup Joe Milton III struggling to find accuracy, the first round of exhibition games gave fans and analysts plenty to discuss.
“The first week of the preseason might not crown champions, but it can set the tone for breakout seasons — or signal trouble ahead,” said NFL analyst Michael Middlehurst-Schwartz in USA Today.
Standout Performers
Shedeur Sanders emerged as one of the biggest storylines, completing 14 of 23 passes for 138 yards and two touchdowns while leading three touchdown drives against the Carolina Panthers. Although the rookie isn’t expected to contend for the starting role immediately, his poise and accuracy have positioned him for more opportunities as the season progresses.
Sanders wasn’t the only name to impress. Tanner McKee of the Philadelphia Eagles turned heads with a 20-of-25 performance for 252 yards and two scores, solidifying his role as Jalen Hurts’ primary backup. The New England Patriots’ TreVeyon Henderson showcased game-breaking speed with a 100-yard kickoff return touchdown, while Cam Little of the Jacksonville Jaguars drilled a remarkable 70-yard field goal, one of the longest ever seen in a preseason contest.
Other notable winners included New York Giants rookie Jaxson Dart, who threw for 154 yards and a touchdown, and Seattle Seahawks wideout Tory Horton, who is pushing for a key role in the passing game. Former NFL running back Marshawn Lynch even made headlines off the field by protecting his camera on the sidelines in true “Beast Mode” fashion.
Struggles and Setbacks
While some players gained momentum, others faced a rocky start. Joe Milton III struggled with accuracy for Dallas, completing just 17 of 29 passes with a touchdown and an interception, raising concerns about his readiness as Dak Prescott’s backup. The Detroit Lions’ Hendon Hooker fumbled twice in a performance that may jeopardize his place in the quarterback rotation.
Indianapolis Colts quarterback Anthony Richardson Sr. faced criticism for a lapse in protection recognition that led to a costly hit. Philadelphia Eagles cornerback Kelee Ringo was burned by Ja’Marr Chase for a long touchdown, adding pressure in his battle for a starting role.
The preseason also saw moments of poor judgment and bad luck. Carolina Panthers receiver Xavier Legette was ejected after a sideline scuffle, while Cowboys star CeeDee Lamb drew an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty despite not playing a snap, after colliding with an official during celebrations.
Looking Ahead
With two more weeks of preseason action, opportunities remain for players to cement their roles or recover from early missteps. Rookies and backups will continue to fight for roster spots, while coaches assess depth and readiness before the regular season kicks off in September.
Fans can track all the preseason developments through NFL.com’s schedule and stats as training camps and exhibition games shape the 2025 campaign. For players like Sanders, the momentum from Week 1 could pave the way for bigger responsibilities, while those on the losing end will need quick turnarounds to keep their NFL dreams alive.